Newspaper Coverage of the Evans & Sontag Story

San Jose Mercury, Saturday morning, August 6, 1892, p. 1, c. 5:

  THE ROBBERS.
Officers Pounce Down Upon Them at Visalia.
A BUNGLING PIECE OF WORK.
A Detective and a Deputy Chased Away and Wounded.
ONE MAN LANDED IN JAIL
The Others Take the Officers' Team and Start for the Woods.
Posse In Pursuit.
 
 
Special to the MERCURY.
VISALIA, August 23. [sic] --Tuesday last Chris Evans and John Sontag hired a livery team in this city to go to the mountains.
Yesterday at noon they returned with the shoes off the horses.
After the Collis train robbery Detectives Thacker and Mickey and Sheriff Cunningham traced the robbers to this city. Before noon to-day Detective Will Smith ask Deputy Sheriff Witty to accompany him to Evan's house in the northern part of town, were he stated he wanted to interview a man.
They went to the house and found George Sontag and took him to jail. They afterward went again to Evans' house and secured a trunk supposed to contain coin. The following is Smith's statement of the occurrence at Evans' house:
"Mr. Witty and myself went down to Chris Evans' house and asked George Conant, alias "Sontag," to step up to the Sheriff's office, as we heard he was on the train that was robbed and we wanted to question him.
"John Sontag was in the house at the time. We brought him [George] to the Sheriff's office where he made a statement and was afterward arrested and charged with robbing the train. Mr. Witty and I then returned to Evans' place. While we were hitching our horses. We asked a little girl in the house were Sontag was, and she said he was not in the house.
"Just then Chris Evans entered the house from the back door. The house consisted of a sitting-room, with a bed-room on the left side. In place of a door to the bed-room there was a portiere. There was another bed-room next to the sitting-room. Evans was in the latter bed-room. He said that Sontag had gone up town. I told him that Sontag had just entered the house.
"I stepped into the house and pulled aside the portieres and there stood Sontag with a double-barreled shot-gun. I stepped to one side and attempted to unbutton my coat to reach my six-shooter, when I saw that Chris Evans had another shot-gun down.
"Witty and I then ran out through the front door. He ran through the gateway and I went over the fence. I turned to the left of the road and Witty to the right. We left the team, as we did not have time to unhitch it. Evans pursued Witty and Sontag pursued me.
"I looked over my shoulder just as Evans fired at Witty. I stopped and fired two shots at Evans, when Sontag stopped and fired at me. As he pulled the trigger I crouched and the charge went over me, but he fired again, his shot striking me in the back and hands. The charge was double B shot.
"As Evans and Sontag continued their pursuit they threw out their empty shells and reloaded their guns. They then took our wagon and drove off, but as one of the horses is stiff I think they will be captured soon. I found in Chris Evans' house the material from which the masks were made, and I also found that the team which the robbers used two night ago was hired here by John Sontag.
"After Evans fired at Witty the latter fell and Evans stepped over him with his gun to fire again when Witty asked him not to shoot again as he was already killed."
Half an hour after Smith and Witty had their encounter with the robbers, a hundred men were in pursuit, but up to the present moment the robbers have escaped. Witty was shot under the right shoulder blade, the bullet coming out under the left arm. His back and one side of his face were well sprinkled with shot from the shot-gun. The cavity of the chest was not penetrated. The opinion is general that if Smith had waited the arrival of Sheriff Cunningham and Detective Thacker the men would have been arrested.
Evans is well acquainted with the mountains east of here, and the chances are that upon reaching the timber he will escape. Evans has a wife and seven children here, and Sontag has been attentive to Evan's oldest daughter. Sontag has been a railroad engineer.
The two men a year ago kept a livery stable at Modesto, which was destroyed by fire. Sontag has been under surveillance of the officers for some time.
 

Return to Oscar Anderson Beaver


This page created on 04/27/01 16:34.