Newspaper Coverage of the Evans & Sontag Story

The San Francisco Examiner, Sunday Morning, February 4, 1894, p. 13:

  CHRIS EVANS' AUTOBIOGRAPHY
_________
 
  The Book the Famous Bandit Wrote Just
Before His Escape From
Fresno Jail.
_________
 
  Voluminous Extracts From the Story of His
Life Told in His Own
Words.
 
  A LIFE FULL OF ADVENTURE.  
    The Outlaw Engaged in Authorship for
 the Purpose of Aiding His Wife and
 His Family, and Has Told His Own
 History From His Birth to the Fight
 With the Officers at Stone Corral - He
 Tells of His Experiences In the Army
 and in Indian Warfare on the Frontier.
   
  _________  
  After Chris Evans was tried and convicted at Fresno he conceived the idea of writing an account of his life. He immediately set to work and the day before he made his escape he completed the manuscript, which will probably soon be given to the world in primer type and yellow paper binding.
Evans' narrative covers his life from his birth to his capture after the famous fight at Stone Corral. Without any attempt at embellishment of any kind Evans tells a plain, matter-of-fact story. He neither brags nor depreciates himself. He makes no threats, no promises, no confession of wrong-doing, and expresses no hopes, desires or ambition.
The detectives have traced back Evans' life for about twenty years. Prior to that his history is somewhat blank although they claim to have discovered enough to connect him with several Union Pacific train robberies that occupied in the early seventies. If Evans' narrative is true in dates and details it covers this unknown ground although it is free from sensational events, and he tells nothing that would implicate him in any crime prior to the time that he took to the Fresno mountains with John Sontag.
A member of the "Examiner" staff has seen Evans' autobiography, and a great part of it is here given in the outlaw's own words without correction or emendation.
 
  _________  
  I was born at Bennington,, Vermont and I first saw the light in a house on the farm, where the Hessians under Baum took position and where brave General Starke said to his men, as he showed them the enemy, "We must take the flag or Mollie Starke sleeps a widow to night."
My parents moved from there to Canada while I was still young, and my life until I was seventeen years old was spent in a quiet way, and I was trained by a loving mother who, when I kissed her good-by, never to see her again in this life, told me to always do what was right, no matter what was the result, and God, would take care of me.
The great struggle for freedom was going on and I left my home and entered the Union army to liberate the slave. I was sent to Harper's Ferry, where Phil Sheridan was collecting an army to drive General Early from the Shenahdoah valley and for six weeks was kept busy learning the duties of a soldier.
On the 19th of August we attacked the Confederate army near Winchester. It was my first battle, and as we marched up to the enemy with drums beating and flags flying I thought it was a grand sight; but before the sun set I looked over a bloody field covered with hundreds of dead and dying comrades, as well as brave Virginians who fell in defense of their homes, and I vowed then never again to take human life unless in self-defense. Three days after we attacked the Confederates at Fisher's Hill, and our brigade was sent to flank the enemy's left. We broke their line and took several hundred prisoners. In this battle I never fired a shot. We then received orders to lay waste [to] the valley, and it was done in a heartless manner by a great many men, principally Illinois regiments. After that work was done we fell back to Cedar creek, where we rested in camp and had a good time generally. Here an incident happened to me which I never regretted, but if the truth of it had been known at the time at the time I would have been court-martialed and shot.
A squad of us under command of Sergeant Baker was on picket duty two miles from camp, on the road leading to Maynesboro, and I was stationed about a quarter of a mile up the road where a county crossroad came in. I hid behind a butternut tree, and while there one of Mosby's men rode up. As he was going by I covered him with my Spencer rifle and ordered him to surrender. He did so, and I told him in answer to his question of what I was going to do with him, that I would take him to headquarters. He begged me with tears in his eyes to let him go, for if I took him to General Sheridan he would be shot. As I looked into his blue eyes and I thought of my faraway home and my dear mother, for he was a boy like myself, and after making a few inquiries as to where he lived. I let him go. I took his horse, and when he was out of sight, I fired a couple of shots, and taking the horse with me went back to Sergeant Baker, and was complimented for my capture of a good horse and saddle.
On the 19th of October while we were cooking breakfast we were attacked by the Confederates. It was a complete surprise, and our men ran without firing a shot. I stayed too long watching the Confederate charge, and when I turned to go I was almost cutoff. I turned to see what our fellows were doing, and finding myself alone, I started for the rear. The Johnnies had flanked us, and when I had got over half a mile away and overtaken several of my comrades, I was ordered by a Confederate officer to stop, with the remark, "Halt, you little Yankee --- -- ----." I told him to go to hell. They fired on me and missed, but just when I was thinking I was out of range a ball struck me below the right knee and knocked me down. I got up and ran on, but staggered and fell after going half a mile, when some of our men carried me back, and during the afternoon I lay under a tree listening to our boys driving the Confederates from our camp. I went to the hospital at Winchester, and when I got well I rejoined my company and afterwards was sent to Monrovia station to guard the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad from bushwhackers. We stayed there till July and then went out to Fort Leavenworth and relieved North Carolina Union troops, who were known as Galvanized Yanks. After resting there a while we went into Western Kansas and built Fort Fletcher, and all that fall and winter we carried the mail to Denver and fought the Cheyennes.
 
  *   *   *   *   *   *   *  
  [Evan's recital of his army experiences on the frontier is long and includes accounts of many skirmishes and battles with the Indians]  
  It was a pitiful sight to see men begging piteously for water, while others were raving mad and trying to sing until death ended their sufferings. One of the recruits named Jackson struck out with me for the river twenty miles away, and we reached the wagon road about 9 o'clock P. M. and crossed it, to find ourselves in a tule swamp, but no water, for the river was hid from view behind a sand ridge. We were in despair, for our brains were in a feverish state and we thought that we imagined we saw a river during the day. We had stripped down to our drawers and our shoes, when the sunset and the mosquitoes tortured us dreadfully, Jackson left me and went back to the road, where he was found by a relief party from an emigrant train that was camped two miles down the road. I held out for some time where I was and starting through the marsh for the road found a spring of water. I shall never forget the sensation I felt at the sight of that water, and after drinking slowly and bathing my heated brow, I filled my canteen and started for the road singing with joy. I found one of my comrades lying in the road, and after giving him a drink I started down the road to get help, for he told me that several of our boys were back from the road, unable to travel, and reached the emigrants camp, one wagon train of Mormons and one of Gentiles going to settle near Pike's Peak in Colorado. They vied with each other in rescuing and taking care of our boys, and one lady who was going to Colorado, after giving several of us a good supper put me in a cozy bed with her own son, and after finding out my past life and where I was from bent over me and kissed me for my mother.  
  *   *   *   *   *   *   *  
  In July my term of service expired and, refusing a tempting offer to re-enlist, I went to work on the Union Pacific, and in one year and a half I saved up $800, which I afterwards spent prospecting and traveling over the country, arriving in San Francisco in May, 1869, where I stayed two weeks, and then went to work on the Western Pacific in Livermore Pass, and had charge of a gang of Chinamen at a tunnel.  
  *   *   *   *   *   *   *  
  An old acquaintance named John Egan, who was born in St. Lawrence county, New York, and now lives in Tipton, Mo, went with me to look for more work. He wanted to go down the coast, while I wanted to go to Calaveras and work in the mines. So to settle it we stood a stick up in the middle of the road and agreed to go the direction in which it fell. It fell in a southeast direction, and we struck out for Visalia, both of us wearing red shirts and accompanied by a dog. * * * At Visalia I went to work for W. R. Owen, commonly known as Pike Bill Owen, and spent nearly two of the happiest years of my life with his family, for his wife was a mother to me and treated me as one of her own, and the children loved me. There I became acquainted with Tom Love, Who was shot by Newt de Masters over a pasture bill. I nursed him until he recovered.
* * * The next spring I left, intending to go home to Canada, but when I reached Visalia I changed my mind and went into the mountains, going to work on the county road and boarding at Jesse Byrd's, where I first became acquainted with my wife. It was a case of love at first sight, never to end in this life, and we were married in her father's house on the 4th day of November, 1874; and went to Hyde's Mill to live, where I had charge. The next fall I thrashed a man named Bigelow for insulting her, and a Visalia jury found me guilty of battery and Judge Clark fined me $100, with the remark that I should not take the law into my own hands. Bigelow died in the spring and his friends claimed that he never recovered from the thrashing he so richly deserved. I was blessed with a loving wife, who proved to be a true helpmate and we never had a quarrel. Our first baby lived only a few hours, and our second boy (Elmer) lived only sixteen months. * * *
In the spring of 1886 I took charge of the Grangers' Bank warehouse at Pixley and Alila, and the following winter their warehouse at Tulare, known as the Farmers' Warehouse, and during the summer of 1887 was manager of that one. There I first made the acquaintance of John Sontag and offered him work in the warehouse as soon as a fanning mill arrived that I had sent for to clean wheat, but before it came he went to work for a threshing outfit and I hired Perry Byrd at $3 per day, when I could have got any man I wanted for $2.50 per day. He worked with me all summer and quit when I turned over the warehouse to F. Miller, and rewarded me for my kindness by bringing me a cart to Wilcox canyon from my wife on the 15th of April 1893, staying with me all day and going back to Visalia and making a bargain for $300 with the Sheriff to post them that I was coming home that night and for them to shoot me as I went away.
 
  [A commonplace recital of events of a commonplace life takes the reader along until the time of the Colfax train robbery and the beginning of Evans' career of murder and outlawry. There is laboring on farms and in the mountains, camping trips to the Sierras, the buying and selling of horses and the shooting of a bear in Bubbs' creek. Evans and John Sontag put $1,500 into a livery stable in Visalia, and Andy McGinnis, who died at Stone Corral, did collecting for them. The stable burned and all was lost. Sontag worked on the railroad, and afterward when his leg was broken was nursed by Evans' wife in her home. Evans tells in detail a story of his trip to Fresno at the time of the Colfax robbery, and what he knew of the doings of John Sontag and George Contant. He tells of his return to Visalia at night and of his keeping away from home all night because he was drunk. Then the story of blood and outlawry goes on in the same calm, matter-of-fact way. It was the next day that the officers in search of the train robbers visited Evans' house and the shooting of Will Smith and Al Witty and the escape occurred.]  
  As I rode out home and when within three blocks of my house a buggy passed me with three men in it. After driving past me it stopped and one man got out, who proved to be Perry Byrd. He waited for me to ride up, and said that he had rode out with two men to show them my house. I asked them why they did not speak to me when they passed if they were going to my house, and he said that Will Hall had sent them out for to bring George Contant up town, that he wanted to have a chat with him for he had been told that George was on the train that had been robbed, and he wanted him to tell what he knew about it. Perry said to me then they think he robbed the train, but are not sure of it. I rode on home and saw him get into the buggy with him and go up town. I went to the barn and split some wood, when John Sontag came to me and said the he would go up town to see what had become of his brother. He went away, and about 1 o'clock my daughter Ines came to the barn and said, "Papa, come to dinner." I put on a light summer coat and going toward the house, saw two men on the front porch, who turned and walked into the house. When I was within twenty feet of them and without saying a word to me I stepped on to the kitchen porch and my wife said to me, "Dinner is ready," and going to the washstand, which was at the pump back of the house, I met Eva running out of the house, when she said to me, "Papa, that man insulted me," meaning Will Smith, who I had never seen before. As I stepped into the hall I looked into her bedroom and picked up a revolver, a forty-four Colt that I always left at home for their protection. I then walked into the parlor and said to the front man. "What in hell do you want!" He said, "Where is John Sontag!" I told him that he went up town, and he replied that he did not do anything of the kind and pulled his gun. I jumped quick to one side, drawing mine as I did so, and he missed me, and both men ran out at the front door, for at that moment John Sontag stepped into the room with a shotgun. I followed them out and ducked down as John Sontag fired. One man ran for the gate [?] and the other, jumping off the corner of the porch, fell headlong into some tomato vines, and I thought Sontag had shot him. I followed the other man over to John Howell's house and shot him, thinking he was the man that had insulted my daughter. When I walked up to him he raised up and begged me not to shoot him any more, for that I had killed him, and I saw that I shot the wrong man, but, like the poor dog Tray, he was in bad company. I went back to my house and put on my shoes, and went out and drove their team to the barn. Sontag when I ducked had fired at Witty, striking him with a few bird shot, and then fired three more shots with the shotgun at Will Smith and never touched him. Smith got up from where he fell and made a jump for the top of the picket fence, about twenty feet to the left of the front gate, and fell flat on his back. He turned over on all fours and butted through the picket fence like a billy-goat, and running past the corner of a wire fence that inclosed a block of land across the street, scratched his hand on it and thought he was shot. John Sontag came out to the buggy with my Ballard rifle and shotgun and we drove out the county lane and stopped at my brother-in-laws, Henry Byrd's place, and watered the team and got a lunch from his wife, telling her that we were going to hunt Grat Dalton.
Friday night we went to Wilcox canyon and I sent a letter to my wife requesting her to meet me at her mother's old ranch in the canyon, but she sent Eva with a letter to me, who brought me all the papers and told me what threats had been made against me, and that they did not intend to take me alive.
Saturday afternoon we heard a man whistling and I went to him and saw Clarke Moore, who told us that Crabtree had told him if he found us to tell us to go away: that a band of Arizona trailers and Apaches were at his house and he did not want any trouble. We started up the trail and that night camped on Pine Ridge, about two hundred yards from the Bear spring and within ten yards of the trail. We could have annihilated the trailers at that place, but we let them pass by on Sunday afternoon, and as they did not return on Monday and we had no bed or food, we started Tuesday morning for Young's cabin to get something to eat. We found some bread and bacon and making some coffee, we satisfied our hunger.
About 9 o'clock I saw a man approaching who I recognized as Mainwaring and I introduced Mr. Sontag to him, and after a few minutes' rest he chatted with us while he soled a pair of shoes and told us of his meeting the posse at different times and Wilson's threats, who he said was their leader. I told him that we saw them go to the valley on Sunday, and we did not think that they would come back, and he asked us what he should do if they found him with us there. I told him that they would kill him if they found him with us and if they came, to take the bucket and go to the spring and keep going. About 11 o'clock I told him to get dinner, for we were hungry, and he was cooking dinner when, looking up, he saw the trailers at the gate, seventy yards from the house, with Wilson in the lead. He exclaimed, "--- ----, here comes the whole gang right on top of us; what shall I do!" John Sontag told him to take the bucket and go quick and not look back. He went out the door and turned the corner of the house and we saw him no more. Four of the trailers dismounted and walked toward the house, while the two Apaches where on foot in the rear. I was sitting inside the window reading a book and John was next to the door. Wilson and McGinnis were in the lead while McGinnis right behind Wilson, and when they were twenty feet from the door I told John to step in the doorway and tell them to stop. He did so and McGinnis who was carrying his Winchester in both hands ready to shoot, and eyeing the house very closely, fired at once. John Sontag dodged to the side of the door and McGinnis missed him. Seeing Wilson pull his pistol I drove my shotgun through the window and fired it, when both men fell. I jumped to the door and fired at the crowd at the gate, and one slug struck Al Witty in the neck, and he howled like a calf. I took my Winchester and charged them, firing at Burke. As he disappeared behind the fence he fired in return and got behind a rock pile near the gate, where he fired again. I got a close shot at him that time, and he ran down the gulch, under cover of the fence, like a jackrabbit. I than turned my attention to the rest, and shot Warren Hill's horse, when he struck out for Sanger through the brush on the hillside, and was last seen on that day carrying a broom on his shoulder when passing Tod's ranch, thinking it was a gun. Will Smith wheeled his horse to escape and clasping his horse round the neck with both hands, put the spurs in his flanks and on the third jump of the horse fell off, losing his gun, revolver and hat and leading Warren Hill and Al Witty established his reputation as a sprinter. Two Indians ran for the rock pile to their left, which commanded the whole place, and went to a big pine log that lay about forty yards to front of them and about thirty feet from where Wilson and McGinnis lay with my back to them. Here my early experience with the Indians won me the day, for whenever the shadow of one of the Apaches showed up I blazed away at him, and Mr. Apache, not caring to expose his head, put his gun up over the rock and shot at me without taking aim. A ball made the bark fly by my side, and I looked quickly in the direction of Burke's flight to see if he was firing at long range. Then, turning, I saw the Apache's head moving slowly out by the rock to get a shot at me, and I had drawn a fine bead on him and was pressing the trigger when a ball struck me from behind and I missed converting Telon into a good Apache.
I was shot through the left eyebrow and turning quickly I saw McGinnis working the lever of his gun to shoot me again. I worked mine and, bringing it quickly to my shoulder shot him through the head. The gun fell from his hands, he quivered a moment and Andy McGinnis climbed the golden stairs.
 
  [Following is Evans' account of the fight at Stone Corral.]  
  I think we were betrayed. I know the men now, although I thought at first it was a mere accident their being at the cabin. Now I believe differently.
We left Fort Defiance on Saturday, the 10th of June and next morning at daylight went into camp on the hill about one mile southwest of the Widow Perkins' house, eat breakfast, and then went to sleep under an oak tree, where we could watch the surrounding country. We woke up and eat our dinner at noon and then watched the Perkins house until 5 o'clock P. M.
I proposed to Mr. Sontag that we go to the house after dark, get our horses, and eat, and drive out the main road, He replied that there was treachery at that place, and that he had been shot at in that cart once and that he would not ride in it any more.
His words were prophetic. I told him it was easier riding then walking and that if we were fired on and badly wounded it would be almost impossible to get back to camp. He insisted on walking, and so that we might reach Visalia in time to go to bed and sleep before daylight, we started at once and took the trail that come out of the hills near the cabin. We carried a shotgun and rifle apiece, intending to hide two of them in Patterson's grain. But as we approached the house we saw the manure and a little straw where an old barn had stood, but which had been torn down and removed, and I walked rapidly to it to see if we could put the guns in it so that we could find them handily when we could come back some other night. I sad down with my right side toward the house and unstrapped my shotgun and looked into the straw. There was a squirrel hole in it next to me, and I was thinking how to cover up the guns when a bullet struck me in the right side and went through my back, grazing the spine. It hit me like a sledgehammer. At the same moment a bullet hit me in the right eye, destroying the sight.
I fell backward; my right had slipped off my Winchester, drawing the hammer partly back and discharging the gun, though I did not know it at the time.
Mr. Sontag was coming to me and said: "Did your gun go off?"
I answered him: "Look out! I'm hard hit." and then another ball struck my right wrist, passing through my arm and coming our near the elbow.
The blood was pouring out from my eye and another stream was running down my back. I rallied and sat up, took my shotgun in my left hand, cocked it and fired both barrels into the house, laid it down -- for I could not put the cartridges into it with one hand -- and took my Winchester.
It snapped so I worked the lever to put in another cartridge, and at that moment I saw a man look around the corner of the house. As I brought my gun to bear on him he stepped quickly back out of sight, but I swung my gun in the direction and sent a bullet through the corner of the house. It struck him, breaking his leg.
I fell over, saying to Mr. Sontag: Goodbye John. I'm done for." and fainted away.
When I came to the sun has set and Mr. Sontag was in my right trying to get a shot at an enemy who was firing at us from a rock pile on a ridge about 300 yards away in the south of us. Mr. Sontag raised up, when he was shot through the shoulder, the ball breaking his right arm. The shot came from a rock pile about 100 yards to the west. I told him to keep down, and asked him where he was shot. He said in the side.
In a little while he raised up again and was shot in the face.
He groaned and moaned pitifully for some time and did not answer me. Then he asked me to kill him and end his misery. I told him to keep up his nerve and when it got dark we would get out of hell hole.
Bullets were plowing the ground under me all the time, and several of them bushed my hair. I could not see twenty feet from me, and drenched with blood and craving a cup of water I had to wait for the coming of night, listening to the sharp crack of the rifles, the screech of the bullets and the heartrending groans of my brave comrade.
I tried repeatedly to get him to go with me, but he did not answer, and I started to creep away. A rapid fire was opened on me and a bullet struck me in the left wrist, breaking it and causing me to leave my rifle.
I straightened up and staggered off, and heard a voice say: "Shoot that damned rascal!"
Bullets whistled around me for some time, but finally ceased; and after a lapse of half an hour I heard three shots, and then all was silent.
I lay down, but could not rest, and tried to find water, but did not succeed.
I could not see now to travel and fell over the rocks and struck trees again and again. With a bullet hold through my back, another through my right arm, my left wrist shattered and a bullet to my head, almost blind, burning up with thirst and weak from loss of blood -- I was helpless.
A rattlesnake lay in the way, but he was kinder to me than those who had shot me, for he gave me warning of his presence, and after I passed he curled up and was found the next day on my trail.
As day dawned I reached the foot of the hill on the other side and, reeling as I walked I made my way to the Cottonwood creek.
I passed by Mr. Dudley's house, but could not open the gate to get a drink of water and went to the creek, tried to scoop out the sand with my feet, but failed, and after resting a few minutes I started up the road that led to the window Parkins' home. I walked into the house, went through the parlor and dining-room to the pump and working the pump handle with my elbow, took a drink.
I went up stairs and lay down on a bed, after some time Mrs. Parkins' grandson came up and said, "Hello, Chris, what's the matter?"
I told him to tell his grandmother to come up, but to say nothing to anyone about me.
My mind was wandering in delirium through the day and I do not remember if I ate anything.
About 11 o'clock P. M. I became conscious and heard men's voices below and then I knew that a posse had arrived.
After several minutes had passed Al Perkins came up the stairs, grabbed both my wrists and said, "You will have to give up."
I said, "Let go my hands; you are hurting me. What's the matter with you!"
Elijah came up and said: "Chris, I have done the best I could for you. The Fresno gang found out where you were and I though it was best to bring Will Hall to you, and they will give the reward to your wife.
I thought [?] that the posse offered Al Perkins $100 to go to me and get me to surrender, for that I might shoot them if they came near me. I told Elijah to bring Will Hall up. He went down and brought him up. Hall said to me:
"Chris, this is too bad. Don't you know me?"
I replied, "You are Will Hall."
"Well, Chris, you are my prisoner."
I answered, "All right." I could not offer resistance if I was ever so willing. He said that he would take me to Visalia and make me as comfortable as possible. There were several men on the stairs behind Hall and they said I was their prisoner. Hot words followed and it looked for a few moments that there would be shooting over me. Sheriff Scott told them to stop, for the law would settle it.
They put me a spring wagon on a good bed and started for Visalia. They were excited and halted every one that came near them and told them to keep away.
When we got to the jail, there was a number of people waiting to see me and shake my hand.
I was placed in a room opposite to the one John Sontag occupied, and a Dr. Matthewson intended me. He was not the county physician.
He amputated my arm and told my wife that she could get it any time. He now refuses to let her have it, with the shallow pretense that some one took it from the place he left it.
John Sontag died on the 3d of July asserting his innocence to the last and was buried in the Catholic Cemetery on the 4th where one lone cedar throws its shadows o'er his grave.

 

Return to Oscar Anderson Beaver


This page created on 10/01/02 19:16.