Newspaper Coverage of the Evans & Sontag Story

Weekly Hanford Journal, Tulare County, Cal., Vol. II, No. 17, 9 Aug 1892, p. 1:

  BOLD TRAIN ROBBERS.  
  ______________________
THEY ROB WELLS, FARGO & CO'S. EX-
PRESS OF A LARGE SUM.

______________
Traced to Visalia and Identified, They Escape
in the Mountains--Two Deputy Sheriffs
Shot, One Fatally--Latest News from the
Seat of War.
______________
 
  Last Wednesday, about midnight, the night express train, south-bound on the S. P. road, was held up near Collis and Wells, Fargo & Co's. express robbed of an amount variously estimated at from $20,000 to $50,000. As the train pulled out of Collis two men boarded the front step of the baggage car and before the train had got far from the station the men put on masks and climbed out over the engine tender, covered the engineer and fireman with pistols and compelled them to run the train out some five miles and there stop the engine. They then proceeded to the express car, after firing a volley of shot alongside the train to intimidate passengers, and blew open the express car with dynamite, eight bombs in all being exploded. -- The robbers used the fireman as a shield. The express messenger, was plucky and would have stood the robbers off had they not used so much dynamite. He came near shooting the fireman. The robbers compelled him to open one of the safes and from it several sacks of coin, said to have been mostly silver, were taken. The robbers compelled the messenger to help them carry the booty to a two-horse buggy which stood near by; then they placed a bomb until one side of the engine and exploded it, to disable the engine; but the bomb did not have the desired results and the engine was repaired and the train pulled into Fresno. A gang of threshers saw the robbery, but they could not prevent it, and they were afraid of killing the train men.  
  TRACING THE ROBBERS.  
  Detectives and robbers were soon on the trail and the robbers were traced to Visalia, where they had arrived about 8 o'clock the next morning. The team had been hired on Tuesday from Bequette & Workman's stable in Visalia and was returned there at noon on Thursday. Chris Evans and George and John Sontag were spotted as the robbers. The officers and detectives were massed at Visalia and tried to agree upon a course of action to arrest the robbers. George Sontag, who rode on the train that was robbed and doubtless did good work in guarding it while his brother and Evans committed the robbery, and taken to jail by the detectives and after being interviewed, he was placed in a cell under suspicion.  
  DEPUTY SHERIFF WITTY SHOT.  
  Then Will Smith, a railroad detective, determined to interview, if not capture, the other two robbers, and he asked Deputy Sheriff George Witty to go with him. The drove out to Evans' house, which is in the north-eastern part of Visalia, with a team belonging to the Sheriff's office, and had H. N. Denny drive his express wagon out there also. The two officers entered the house just after seeing Evans and John Sontag enter. They found Evans in a front room. They asked for Sontag and Evans said he was not there. Smith pulled aside a portiere and exposed to view Sontag with a double-barreled shotgun. Sontag and Evans then chased Smith and Witty out of the house, firing at the fleeing officers as they ran. Witty was followed by Evans, who fired into his back with shot as he ran and then shot him in the face with a pistol. He then place his pistol at Witty's head and said he would blow his brains out. Witty made a pitiful plea for mercy and Evans then left him. Sontag followed Smith and fired twice at him, but only a few shot hit him and he was not seriously injured. He jumped into the express wagon and ordered Mr. Denny to drive him swiftly to town, leaving his companion at the mercy of the desperate robbers.  
  THE ROBBERS ESCAPE AND THEN RETURN.  
  The robbers, after taking the officers' team, drove to Stokes Valley, and spent the day on the side of a hill 20 miles N. E. of Visalia. Here they remained until nightfall. In the meantime there were many officers and citizens out hunting for them, but they were not located. That night the robbers drove back to Evan's house in Visalia, arriving about there midnight. They no doubt came back after the stolen treasure, which was probably hid under the floor of the barn.  
  DEPUTY SHERIFF BEAVER SHOT.  
  Several guards had been placed about the Evans house. About midnight Dan Overall came into Visalia and said he wanted more guards, as the moon was going down and it would soon be dark. Oscar Beaver, a deputy Sheriff from Lemoore, and Charles Hall, Constable and Deputy Sheriff from Hanford, who had gone up to Visalia that evening, agreed to go. Beaver was stationed 20 yards from the barn. He saw one of the robbers and asked who it was. Beaver and the robbers then commenced firing. Beaver fired eight shots from his revolver and the robbers fired four times with their shotguns. Beaver was riddled with shot from head to foot. He cried out for help, but it was an hour before assistance reached him, as those near him were afraid they would meet the same fate as Beaver if they ventured near him.
Beaver shot both the horses and the robbers were compelled to leave on foot. They had the tires of the buggy padded with rags, tied on with strings, and they evidently intended to make a noiseless drive out of town.
 
  ESCAPED TO THE MOUNTAINS.  
  The robbers walked some 12 miles north of Visalia to Cottonwood, where they took breakfast soon after daylight at the farm of Harvey Ward. The robbers were very talkative and told Ward and another man who was there that they had got into trouble in Visalia and had killed a man. They asked Ward if he had a daily paper, as they would like to know who it was they had killed. Said he was a gritty little fellow, as he had fired several shots after they had given him his death wounds. The robbers took a mule and cart from Ward and the last seen of them they were making for the mountains. Evans has a mine 10 miles west of Camp Badger. There he has provisions and that was probably the place the robbers were making for when last seen. They abandoned the mule and cart at Nigger creek gulch, in the Sierra foothills, where they were afterwards found.  
  BEAVER'S DEATH AND FUNERAL.  
  Oscar Beaver died at 2:30 last Saturday afternoon and his remains taken to Lemoore that night. The funeral services were held at the Baptist church in Lemoore on Sunday, Rev. Eli Rees conducting the services. Many people followed the remains to their last resting place. He leaves a wife and two year old boy.
On Saturday Deputy Coroner Holder impaneled a jury, who examined the body of Beaver and on Sunday witnesses were examined. The jury returned a verdict that Oscar A Beaver, a native of California, aged 34 years, came to his death from gunshot wounds inflicted by Chris Evans and John Sontag. Warrants have been issued for Evans and Sontag on charges of murder.
 
  DESCRIPTION OF THE CRIMINALS.  
  Chris Evans is a married man, having a wife and seven children. His wife is a sister of O. P. and Frank Bird. She was in a dangerous condition on Sunday, as a result of the shock of the discovery of her husband's actions and anxiety for his safety. Evans has resided in Visalia for the past 15 years. Following is a description of the escaped robbers: Chris Evans, age 45, height five feet nine inches, weight 170 pounds, red mustache, long chin and beard; John Sontag, 33 years old, height five feet ten inches, weight 180 pounds, brown hair, sandy mustache, limps slightly from a broken leg.  
  TRAILING THE MURDERERS.  
  Sheriff Kay was not in Visalia at the times these stirring incidents were transpiring, but over on the Coast after a Portuguese for whom he had a warrant of arrest. The Sheriff, after a long chase over the Coast Range mountains after his man, arrested him at Santa Cruz at 2 o'clock P. M. on Friday, and 1 hour later he received a telegram announcing the shooting of his deputy, Witty. He returned home last Saturday night and immediately took charge of the chase after the robbers. Since the return of the Sheriff the search for the robbers has been much more thorough and systematic. The officers are now doing their work quietly and none of them will say what they have been doing for the past two days. Mum is the word and it is a good one in such instances.  
  THE LATEST NEWS.  
  Constable Hall of Hanford returned from Visalia this morning. From him and from other sources we learn that a stock man arrived in Visalia yesterday evening and reported that the robbers were again coming back to Evans' home; that they were riding in a buckboard drawn by one horse. Many officers and citizens went to Evans' house and made a thorough search of the premises, but could find no trace of the robbers. Several of the roads leading into the city were guarded, but the robbers did not put in an appearance. There are many men out in the hills and mountains after the robbers, who are generally believed to be at Evans' mine, at Sampson Flat.
Deputy Sheriff Witty is doing well and the doctors attending him think that he will recover.
 
 

 

Weekly Hanford Journal, Tulare County, Cal., Vol. II, No. 18, 16 Aug 1892, p. 4:
(Editorial page)

  ______________  
  The Examiner has made the discovery that Oscar Beaver was one of the principals in a mysterious saloon row in San Francisco last February and that he then, accidently or otherwise, shot a man in the thigh. This is only one of the great discoveries made by the Examiner. Some man told a reporter that George Sontag was a real nice gentleman and then the informant went on to relate how Sontag once drew his pistol in a ball-room and compelled the young men present to dance with a girl who was objectionable to those present. Last Sunday three columns was devoted to telling what nice men Chris Evans and John Sontag were. Apparently the only one who deserves any censure in this robbery business is Sheriff Kay and other officers whose ability and honestly of purpose are held up to ridicule nearly every day in the Examiner.  
  ______________
______________
 
 

 

Return to Oscar Anderson Beaver


This page created on 04/24/03 21:54.